Jing Tang uses cyathula. Natural Path uses Achryanthes (as does Evergreen). I'd like to use Si Miao San for a Cushing's dog.
Jen
Question Details
Cyathula Vs Achryanthes
by
jenmercier
-
November 9, 2024
Jing Tang uses cyathula. Natural Path uses Achryanthes (as does Evergreen). I'd like to use Si Miao San for a Cushing's dog.
Jen
Replies
by
naturevet
November 10, 2024
Hi Jen,
Cyathula has a much more limited range of effects in the body than Achyranthes, and was thus the herb that was used traditionally. Jing Tang may be using Cyathula because it is cheaper, but I think it's more important to use what the ancients use, as they were aware of both plants, but chose Achyranthes. That to me is meaningful, and explained by the broader range of effects of Achyranthes
Hope that helps!
Steve
Cyathula has a much more limited range of effects in the body than Achyranthes, and was thus the herb that was used traditionally. Jing Tang may be using Cyathula because it is cheaper, but I think it's more important to use what the ancients use, as they were aware of both plants, but chose Achyranthes. That to me is meaningful, and explained by the broader range of effects of Achyranthes
Hope that helps!
Steve
Reply to this question.
You must be logged in to reply